
Fiber cement and vinyl each have their own rules for cutting, painting and fastening. Here is what manufacturers say to watch for, and what to ask before you choose.

Siding changes how your home looks and how it handles water, sun and temperature swings. Fiber cement and vinyl are both common in Richmond, and each has its own installation rules. Every house brings its own challenges, so here is what the manufacturers and public sources say to plan for.
For a side-by-side comparison of the two materials, read Hardie Board vs. Vinyl Siding in Virginia. This article focuses on what can go wrong.
Virginia's statewide building code (13VAC5-63-80, Section 108) exempts replacing any amount of siding on a one- or two-family home from a permit, as long as the home is not in an area where the design wind speed is greater than 100 mph. The local building official may require a permit for replacement siding in a locally designated historic district.
Chesterfield County's pages list repairing siding and installing vinyl siding among the work that does not require a permit. They do not say anything specific about replacing all of a home's siding with another material, so ask the county before you start. Henrico and the City of Richmond may differ.
The U.S. EPA says asbestos may be found in roofing and siding shingles, and that exposure may occur only when the material is disturbed or damaged. Home repair and remodeling can disturb it. If your home is older and your siding is original, tell your contractor before any cutting or removal begins.
James Hardie products are sold through dealers and suppliers, and the company has a dealer locator on its Pros Hub page. Vinyl is sold by many suppliers. Prices change often and vary by store, color and profile, so the table below is a snapshot. The best way to compare is to ask each contractor for the brand, product line and trim in writing.
Pro tip: Ask whether the siding will be primed, pre-finished or unpainted, and who is responsible for the paint schedule. Fiber cement has a painting deadline that is easy to miss.
For our work, see Siding Installation & Replacement in Chesterfield & Richmond, VA.
These are retail prices for materials only, read on the Menards website on November 17, 2026, before any rebate or discount. They are not MAS Contractors prices, they do not include labor, and they change by store, season and stock. We list them so you can see how materials compare, not to estimate your project. Every job is different, so ask for a free estimate.
| Material | Example product | Retail price |
|---|---|---|
| Vinyl siding | Cedar Creek Double 4 in, 12 ft 6 in | $5.61 each |
| Vinyl siding | TimberCrest Premium Double 4 in, white, 12 ft 6 in | $9.54 each |
| Vinyl siding | TimberCrest Premium Plus ColorFast Double 4 in, 12 ft 6 in | $12.35 each |
| Fiber cement lap | Allura 5/16 in x 12 ft, textured | $14.99 each |
| Fiber cement lap | Allura 5/16 in x 12 ft, smooth | $26.99 each |
| Engineered wood lap | LP SmartSide 3/8 in x 8 in x 16 ft, textured | $16.99 each |
| Engineered wood lap | LP SmartSide 3/8 in x 12 in x 16 ft, brushed smooth | $29.99 each |
These are prices per piece, and pieces cover different amounts of wall, so compare the coverage per piece and not only the price. A search for HardiePlank on Menards showed Allura fiber cement instead; James Hardie products are sold through dealers and some home improvement stores, and its Pros Hub page has a dealer locator. The Home Depot prices follow below.
These are retail prices for materials only, read on the Home Depot website with the delivery ZIP code set to 23236 and the Midlothian store, on November 17, 2026. Some items show a sale price. They are not MAS Contractors prices, they do not include labor, and they change by store, season and stock. We list them so you can see how materials compare, not to estimate your project. Every job is different, so ask for a free estimate.
| Material | Example product | Retail price |
|---|---|---|
| Fiber cement lap (James Hardie) | Hardie Plank HZ5, 8.25 in x 144 in, primed, Cedarmill | $20.58 each ($17.49 each for 25 or more) |
| Fiber cement lap (James Hardie) | Hardie Plank HZ5, 8.25 in x 144 in, primed, beaded smooth | $21.75 each ($18.49 each for 25 or more) |
| Fiber cement lap (James Hardie) | Hardie Plank HZ10, 8.25 in x 144 in, primed, beaded smooth | $16.62 each ($14.13 each for 25 or more) |
| Engineered wood lap (LP) | LP SmartSide Cedar Texture, 3/8 in x 8 in x 16 ft | $15.48 each |
| Engineered wood lap (LP) | LP SmartSide 38 Series Cedar Texture, 8 in x 12 ft | $13.48 each |
The same Home Depot search listed Hardie Plank in other colors, including the Statement Collection, as special order, with pricing and availability handled through its Pro Desk. Special orders and color choices are two reasons to plan siding before the work starts.
MAS Contractors LLC
Licensed Class A General Contractor · Richmond, VA · Serving Chesterfield, Henrico, Midlothian & surrounding areas since 2013.



Serving Richmond, North Chesterfield, Midlothian, Glen Allen, and Henrico. Licensed, insured, and ready to start.
DID WE WORK ON YOUR HOME?
Your Google review helps other Richmond homeowners choose a contractor.